The principal law regulating companies is the Enterprise Law
2005 (EL). The EL governs all domestic and foreign-invested companies.
Types of enterprises
The EL provides for three types of enterprise, being:
- limited liability companies
- partnerships
- private enterprises.
Limited liability
companies
For foreign investment purposes, the main types of
investment vehicles are the following:
- one member limited liability company. These are commonly
known as “One Member LLCs”
- two members or more limited liability company. The number
of members must not exceed fifty. These are commonly known as “Two Member LLCs”
- shareholding company. These are known as “Joint Stock
Companies”, or “JSCs”. The minimum number of shareholders is three and there
are no restrictions on the maximum number of shareholders. Shareholding
companies may issue securities to the public to attract capital in accordance
with Vietnam’s legislation on securities.
In general, the first two types of limited liability
companies are more common for foreign investors, although companies that are
considering listing on the stock exchange will want to be a JSC as only JSCs
can be listed. JSCs also provide more flexibility for transferring equity.
One major difference between an LLC and a JSC is that
although shares are issued in a JSC, shares are not issued in an LLC. Equity is
subscribed, and although it can be assigned, it is subject to pre-emptive
rights in favor of the other shareholders.
Partnerships
A partnership is an enterprise in which there must be at
least two unlimited liability partners who jointly own the partnership. In
addition to these, there may be limited liability partners. Unlimited liability
partners are liable for the liabilities and obligations of the partnership to
the extent of all their assets, while limited liability partners are only
liable for the debts of the partnership to the extent of the amount of capital
they have contributed to the partnership.
Private enterprises
A private enterprise is an enterprise owned by one
individual who is liable for all activities of the enterprise to the extent of
all their assets. An individual is entitled to establish one private enterprise
only.
Lines of business
When registering a company in Vietnam, the applicant must
state the scope of business. If the Vietnamese company wants to undertake
business outside the stated scope, it must apply for approval. The application
must state precisely the proposed scope.
Investment Law 2005
(IL)
The IL governs the investment activities in Vietnam of
foreign and local individuals and legal entities. The WTO Schedule (considered
below) is also important for foreign investment. Under the IL, investors can
invest directly or indirectly in all types of business that are not
specifically prohibited or restricted. The IL provides for the following types
of direct investment:
Establishment of a
company
Investors can establish companies in accordance with the EL.
These may be wholly owned or jointly owned subject to any WTO restrictions. In
some industries, investors must also comply with the conditions laid down in
the relevant laws (such as Law on Credit Institutions for banking and financial
services, Law on Petroleum for petroleum businesses, Law on Civil Aviation of
Vietnam for aviation business, Law on Education for schools, Law on Securities
for securities business, and Law on Insurance Business for insurance business).
Investment under
contracts
Investors are permitted to sign contracts in the forms of
business cooperation contracts (BCC), build, operate, transfer (BOT), build,
transfer, operate (BTO) and build, transfer (BT) for cooperation in production,
sharing profits and sharing products and other forms of cooperation.
Investment for business expansion
- Investors are permitted to invest in the expansion of
existing businesses through the:- expansion of the scale of business or increase of
production capacity
- renovation of technology, increase of product quality or
measures for reduction of environmental pollution.
Purchase of shares or contribution of capital Investors are
permitted to purchase shares or contribute capital to an economic entity
operating in Vietnam at the rates stipulated by the Government.
Merger and
acquisition
Investors are permitted to carry out mergers or acquisitions
of a company operating in Vietnam, subject to any restrictions on foreign
ownership. In addition, investors are permitted to invest indirectly by way of
the purchase of bonds, investment fund certificates and other securities, and
by way of the establishment of investment funds.
Conditional
investment
Sectors in which investment is conditional include:
- radio and television broadcasting
- production, publishing and distribution of cultural
products
- exploration and mining of minerals
- establishment of infrastructure for telecommunication
networks, transmission and the provision of internet and telecommunication
services
- establishment of a public postal network and provision of
postal services and express services
- construction and operation of river ports, sea ports,
terminals and airports
- transportation of goods and passengers by railway, roadway
and sea and inland waterways
- fisheries
- production of tobacco
- real estate business
- import, export and distribution business
- education and training
- hospitals and clinics
- other investment sectors related to international treaties
to which Vietnam is a member and which restrict the opening of the market to
foreign investors.
Prohibited projects
The following projects are prohibited to foreign investment:
- projects which are prejudicial to national security,
defense or the public interest
- projects which are detrimental to historical and cultural
relics or the customs and traditions of Vietnam
- projects that may adversely affect people’s health, spoil
resources or destroy the environment
- projects which deal with the provision of harmful waste
into Vietnam, projects for the production of toxic chemicals or which utilize
toxic agents prohibited under an international treaty
- other investment projects prohibited in accordance with the
provision of laws.
Recognized forms of doing business in Vietnam The most
common business structures used by foreign investors in Vietnam include:
- wholly owned subsidiaries
- joint venture companies
- business co-operation contracts
- foreign contractors.
Alternatively, foreign investors may also operate by
establishing:
- representative offices
- branches.
Foreign investors may also invest indirectly in Vietnam, in
the following ways:
- purchase of shareholding, shares, bonds and other valuable
papers
- by way of securities investment funds
- by way of other intermediary financial institutions.
However, there are restrictions on the level of foreign
ownership of shares in Vietnamese companies in various sectors including the
following:
- listed shares
- banking
- petroleum
- aviation
- general insurance
- publishing
- education
- media
- telecommunications
- mining.
WTO Schedule
The WTO Schedule sets out the timing for when foreign
investors may invest in a wide range of services as well as the percentage
ownership that may be held. Since 2007, many restrictions have been lifted.
Although many restrictions on foreign investment were lifted
on 1 January 2009, in practice major problems remain (and can be noted in the
retail, wholesale and franchising sectors). Applications for approval are dealt
with extremely slowly and are subject to extremely detailed analysis. As an
example of these restrictions in practice, Vietnam is one of the few countries
in which there are no McDonalds or Starbucks stores.
Even if a foreign investor is allowed to open one retail
outlet, any other outlet will be subject to an economic needs test which gives
the authorities very wide scope to reject any application.
Establishment of an
entity
Foreign investors are permitted to establish enterprises in
accordance with the EL through the following types of entities:
- limited liability enterprises
- joint stock enterprises
- partnership enterprises
- private enterprises.
Foreign investors directly investing in Vietnam must have an
approved investment project and are not permitted to simply establish a
company. Approval is given for investment in a project, and the company is
merely the vehicle for the project. Typically, approval is obtained from the
Department of Planning and Investment of the local provincial or city People’s
Committee. If the application is successful, the People’s Committee issues an
investment certificate for the project. The investment certificate also serves
as the Business Registration Certificate. Domestic companies with no foreign
investment are issued with a Business Registration Certificate.
Business Co-operation
Contract (BCC)
A Business Co-operation Contract is a contract signed by two
or more parties to carry out investment without establishing a legal entity. A
BCC operates on the basis of mutual allocation of responsibilities and sharing
of profits, production and losses. As defined under the IL, a BCC does not
create a separate legal entity under Vietnamese law but the parties to the BCC
are issued with an investment licence. To the extent that a BCC is not a legal
entity distinct from its constituent partners, it is similar to a partnership.
It is often known as a joint operating company (JOC), and is a structure that
is commonly used in the petroleum industry.
The IL does not stipulate in detail the rights and
obligations of the parties to a BCC. It is important that the rights and
responsibilities of the parties be comprehensively set out in the BCC.
Foreign contractors
There are certain businesses, especially in the service
sector, where foreign investors may do business in Vietnam as foreign
contractors without engaging in any form of investment prescribed under the IL.
The following types of activities undertaken by a foreign entity are recognised
and subject to tax on income that they generate in Vietnam (foreign
contractor’s tax):
- commerce, including distribution or supply of goods,
material, machinery and equipment
- services
- construction and installation, other production and
transportation
- lending
- licensing.
Foreign contractors in the fields of investment and
construction, provision of material, equipment and technology together with
technical services in respect of construction and the provision of construction
services are required to be licensed by the Ministry of Construction or the
Department of Construction of the provincial People’s Committee, depending on
the value of the project concerned. This licensing regime is project specific.
Representative
offices
If a foreign company wishes to have a presence in Vietnam
before actually investing, it may set up a representative office. The company
must have operated for at least one year in its country of establishment.
A foreign representative office is not permitted to carry on
any production or sales activities, nor is it permitted to earn income in
Vietnam. Its main functions are to coordinate trade and transactions between
the head office of the foreign company and Vietnamese businesses, to study the
feasibility of investment in Vietnam and to undertake business development activities.
A license for the establishment of a representative office of a foreign
business entity in Vietnam has a duration of five years.
Branches of foreign
companies
A license for establishment of a branch of a foreign
business entity in Vietnam conducting the purchase and sale of goods, and
activities directly related to the purchase and sale of goods, has a duration
of five years. In some specific areas, including banking, branches are
permitted under the relevant law.
Investment in Vietnamese companies
With limited exceptions (e.g., the banking and insurance
sectors), foreign individuals and organizations are allowed to purchase up to a
maximum of 49 percent of the issued shares of a listed Vietnamese enterprise.
Further, with certain exceptions, foreign investors may invest in or acquire
the whole or a part of the equity interest in unlisted Vietnamese companies,
subject to the business scope of the Vietnamese company concerned.